| José Paolo Guerrero Gonzales | 5 | Perú |
| Luis Alberto Suárez Díaz | 4 | Uruguay |
| Sergio Leonel Agüero Del Castillo | 3 | Argentina |
| Felipe Salvador Caicedo Corozo | 2 | Ecuador |
| Neymar Da Silva Santos Junior | 2 | Brasil |
| Diego Forlán Corazo | 2 | Uruguay |
| Radamel Falcao García Zárate | 2 | Colombia |
| Álvaro Daniel Pereira Barragán | 2 | Uruguay |
| Alexandre Rodrigues da Silva | 2 | Brasil |
| Antolín Alcáraz Viveros | 1 | Paraguay |
| Juan Fernando Arango Sáenz | 1 | Venezuela |
| Néstor Alejandro Araujo | 1 | México |
| Lucas Ramón Barrios Arioli | 1 | Paraguay |
| Joel Nathaniel Campbell Samuels | 1 | Costa Rica |
| Federico Chaves Guedes | 1 | Brasil |